The State of Me

Comments

That's when people starting talking about "deserving" aid. It crystallized in the hurricanes, when many Americans turned on the victims of the hurricanes, blaming them and accusing them even before the hurricanes were completely over.
Well, I'm one of those who speaks of "deserving aid", but I approach it from a different direction [1]. IMHO, if you live on the Gulf Coast without insurance and get hit by a hurricane, then society owes you nothing. If you live in California without insurance and get hit by an earthquake, then society owes you nothing. If you live in Oklahoma without insurance and get hit by a tornado, then society owes you nothing.

What if you do have insurance? Then what society owes you is making certain that those insurers pay the claims and don't try to weasel out of it. That's it. The rest of it is up to you, as an adult.

My beef with Federal Disaster Aid is manifold:
1) It subsidizes poor choices. Without Federal Aid, people would move away from the disaster area, or would build less expensive structures instead of more expensive ones.
2) It subsidizes poor planning. When the government pays people to repair their houses in a disaster zone, it just sets the stage for it all to happen all over again as people are not made to pay for their mistakes.
3) It encourages passivity. Why did so many people stay in New Orleans during Katrina [2]? Because they had been assured that the government would take care of them. If they had been told that they were on their own and wouldn't get diddly-squat, more would have left and fewer lives would have been lost.
Is it tragic that so many are hurt by disasters? Yes. Is it society's responsibility to make sure that they aren't hurt? No. It is society's job to make sure that they have the opportunity to heal themselves.

John

[1] So what else is new?
[2] Which, as I have pointed out elsewhere, could have been much, much worse.
Ah well, you and I have never seen eye to eye on a lot of things.

The problem I saw was that people were attacking the victims even before the hurricanes were completely over, blaming them. And yanno? If I had lived in New Orleans at the time, I would have been among those who didn't evacuate because my boss would have required I keep working. Not being in a position to find a new job at my age, I'd have stayed at work and taken my chances with the weather. I'd be among those condemned for not getting out, for being under-insured, for being too desperate to keep my job to risk being safe.

I've lived below and at the edge of poverty all my life. I understand poverty. I firmly believe <i>no one</i> deserves to be hungry, or homeless, and no one should have to prove they are "worthy" in order to eat or have a safe place to sleep.

But that's me - a soft touch.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in